Marriage Law Home
 
  Home Legislation and Policy Issues and Arguments Case and Statute Law Current News My Community  
Last Updated: 09.08.2004

Current News

Year to Date

Archives

 

TOP6NEWS - September 8, 2004


1-NEWS:  Another WA judge strikes down state DOMA

2-NEWS:  UT high court rejects bigamy case

3-NEWS:  WV Supreme Court will hear lesbian custody petition

4-NEWS:  Lesbian custody dispute in IN

5-OP-ED:  More gay parents sparking discussion in schools

6-OP-ED HI man files federal suit over public-property access

________________________________________________________

1-NEWS: Another WA judge strikes down state DOMA

Decision at:
http://www.co.thurston.wa.us/superior/Recent%20Opinions/Castle%20v%20State%20-%20Memorandum%20Opinion.pdf

Second judge rules against state's gay marriage ban
By TRACY JOHNSON
SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER REPORTER
http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/189871_marriage08.html?searchpagefrom=1&searchdiff=0

A second judge struck down the state's ban on same-sex marriage yesterday, finding that it doesn't serve a valid purpose and may instead weaken families who are trying to make stable homes for children.

Thurston County Superior Court Judge Richard Hicks also took the unusual step of ruling that gays and lesbians are a "suspect class," meaning that any law treating them differently must be looked at extra carefully, as is the case with classifications based on race.

The issue is headed for the state Supreme Court and will almost certainly emerge in the Legislature next year -- possibly in the form of a proposed constitutional amendment that would ensure people of the same sex can't marry.

Hicks declined to give any guidance yesterday on whether lawmakers could choose to create "different kinds of domestic unions or partnerships" called something other than marriage, as a state attorney urged last week.

...

BACK TO TOP

________________________________________________________

2-NEWS: UT high court rejects bigamy case

Utah high court rejects challenge to state's anti-bigamy law
By The Associated Press
09.07.04
http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/news.aspx?id=13999
SALT LAKE CITY — The Utah Supreme Court on Sept. 3 denied an appeal from a man convicted of having five wives who argued that the state’s anti-bigamy law violated his First Amendment right to religious freedom.

Attorney John Bucher had argued polygamy was part of Tom Green’s religion, and that Utah’s laws for cohabitation were so vague that Green had no way to know he was in violation.

A unanimous Supreme Court disagreed, however, noting Utah’s bigamy statute “does not attempt to target only religiously motivated bigamy. Any individual who violates the statute, whether for religious or secular reasons, is subject to prosecution.”

...

BACK TO TOP

________________________________________________________

3-NEWS: WV Supreme Court will hear lesbian custody petition

West Virginia Supreme Court to hear lesbian custody petition
By the Associated Press
Published September 3, 2004
http://www.dailypress.com/news/local/virginia/dp-brf--gayparents0903sep03,0,5939878.story?coll=dp-headlines-virginia
CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- The West Virginia Supreme Court has agreed to decide whether state law recognizes the parental rights of same-sex partners.

Tina Burch is appealing for custody of the 4-year-old son of her lesbian partner, Christina D. Smarr, who died in a 2002 car accident. Within hours of Smarr's death, Smarr's brothers-in-law took the child from Burch and handed him over to his grandparents.

A lower court ruled in December that state law does not give a homosexual the right to win legal guardianship of a former partner's child; Burch appealed.

...

BACK TO TOP

________________________________________________________

4-NEWS:  Lesbian custody dispute in IN

Same-Sex Couple's Breakup Sparks Custody Battle
Judge Rules Adoptive Mother Must Return Boy To Indiana For Now
POSTED: 8:44 pm EST September 3, 2004
http://www.theindychannel.com/news/3706357/detail.html
NOBLESVILLE, ind. -- Who gets custody of a boy when his two mothers break up? The Hamilton County court system is trying to figure that out.

On Friday, a judge ruled that a 4-year-old boy who moved to Georgia in July with his adoptive mother must return to Indiana, where his biological mother is jailed.

Nancy Lafferty, who adopted the boy while she was in a romantic relationship with the biological mother, Jill Wihebrink, must either move back to Indiana or allow the child to temporarily live with Wihebrink's Indiana family. The boy must return to the state in a week.

...

BACK TO TOP

________________________________________________________

5-OP-ED: More gay parents sparking discussion in schools

Posted on Wed, Sep. 08, 2004
More gay parents a point of discussion for students, schools
BY ROBERT DODGE
The Dallas Morning News
http://www.charlotte.com/mld/charlotte/news/nation/9608244.htm
WASHINGTON - (KRT) - The nation's schools, a historic battleground for social controversy, are wrestling with a variety of gay and lesbian issues. The latest: a wave of children with same-sex parents is reaching school age.

Nationwide, about 250,000 children have same-sex parents - a trend not limited to cities with large gay populations, according to census data culled by Gary Gates at the nonpartisan Urban Institute.

"The highest portions of same-sex couples with children are in the South," said Gates. The reason: He surmises that gays who grew up in the conservative Sunbelt value family and want to start their own.

Gay issues have stirred conflict and parental concerns for years, as students have pushed cultural boundaries by forming gay-straight clubs, bringing same-sex dates to proms and resisting harassment and bullying. Now, as gay parents send their kids off to school, new concerns are being raised, reflecting anxiety about premature questions from children regarding human sexuality.

"It is amazing how inquisitive 5- and 6-year-olds can be when they are exposed to someone with two moms who are lesbians," said Tony Perkins, president of the Family Research Council, a conservative advocacy group. "This is a very good example of how homosexual marriage impacts other families."

Educators said they have to be sensitive to those concerns but said they do not reflect what happens at school.
"The whole question is naive. It assumes a school district is going to teach sexuality at the first grade," said Christopher Maddox, who teaches in Dallas at Sam Houston Elementary.

Ellen Herbert, who teaches at Longview High School in East Texas, added: "I would never suggest that we go into any classroom and promote homosexuality. That is a non-issue."

Even so, gay issues and schools create conflict – especially because children and human sexuality are involved.
In Lafayette, La., last fall, a 7-year-old was sent home with a disciplinary note after telling a classmate that his two moms are gay, which he defined as "when a girl likes a girl." The note Marcus McLaurin carried home said: "This kind of discussion is not acceptable in my room." And, in the report, Marcus wrote, "I sed bad wurds" in describing his family.

...

BACK TO TOP

________________________________________________________

6-OP-ED: HI man files federal suit over public-property access

Hawaii sued over public-property access
By B.J. Reyes, Associated Press Writer  |  September 8, 2004
http://www.newsday.com/news/nationworld/nation/wire/sns-ap-hawaii-free-speech,0,2843845.story
HONOLULU -- A man who was kicked out of the Hawaii State Library for using its computers to access a gay and lesbian Web site filed a federal lawsuit Tuesday challenging a state law that allows authorities to ban people from public property.

The law prohibits people from entering a public place for up to one year after a written warning or request to leave the premises has been issued. It was aimed at removing squatters from public campgrounds, parks and beaches.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Hawaii, filing on behalf of Carlos Hernandez, said people or groups could be thrown off public property for no reason and said the law could be used to keep voters out of polling places or to bar groups such as native Hawaiians from the grounds of the state Capitol.

...

BACK TO TOP



       
       
  Columbus School of Law